Home Magazine Why the Chicaaaaago Accent Is Actually a New York One

Why the Chicaaaaago Accent Is Actually a New York One

Actor Robert Forster talked robust. His laborious consonants and elongated vowels made him good for the position of streetwise bail bondsman Max Cherry in Jackie Brown. Forster appeared and seemed like a cop, so casting administrators put him in the identical class as Dennis Farina and Dennis Franz, which made folks imagine he shared the identical background as Chicago’s all-star Dennises.

When Forster appeared on NPR’s Fresh Air in 2003, host Dave Davies quizzed him about his accent. “I at all times assumed you had been from Chicago,” Davies stated. “Possibly that’s as a result of I noticed you within the film adaptation of David Mamet’s Lakeboat.” (Forster additionally starred in one of many nice Chicago motion pictures, enjoying a TV information photographer in Medium Cool.)

“I’m from Rochester, which is a Nice Lakes accent,” Forster responded. “So Rochester, Buffalo, Erie—not Detroit a lot—however Chicago, and nearly all these cities have the same accent, a protracted A. I do know I sound that method. Not a lot to do about it, simply acquired to stay with what you bought.”

That’s Rochester, New York, not Rochester, Michigan. Regardless that Chicago and Rochester are 600 miles aside, the 2 cities share practically an identical speech patterns. Dat’s proper: what we name a Chicago accent is, the truth is, an Upstate New York accent, transplanted right here within the 19th Century by the town’s earliest residents. We discuss extra like Rochester and Buffalo than Bloomington and Peoria.

Why? Linguists say it’s because of the Erie Canal. The now-defunct waterway, which handed by Syracuse, Rochester and Buffalo, funneled the migration of New Yorkers westward towards Lake Erie, and from there, to the Nice Lakes ports of Cleveland, Detroit, Chicago and Milwaukee. Collectively, these cities type what’s generally known as the Inland North dialect area.

“The settlement of the Inland North was intently related with the development of the Erie Canal,” noticed linguist William Labov and his fellow co-authors within the Atlas of North American English: Phonetics, Phonology and Sound Change. These New Yorkers spoke with an accent derived from western Massachusetts and Vermont, the properties of their very own forebears.

“[E]ven earlier than the canal was constructed, guests from the Jap Seaboard famous the distinct accent of the villagers in Buffalo and Black Rock,” writes Buffalo journalist Jeff Z. Klein. “After the canal opened, hundreds of settlers from New York State carried that accent to northern Ohio, Michigan and points west. Inside a few a long time, the Inland North accent and its shifting vowels had unfold throughout your complete American Nice Lakes area.”

It’s not laborious to seek out cultural hyperlinks between Upstate New York and northern Illinois, both. 4 of the town’s first 5 mayors had been born in New York State, starting with William Ogden, of Walton. Northwestern College’s Garrett-Evangelical Seminary was based by John Dempster, a Methodist preacher from the “Burned-Over District,” because the area was known as due to its position in 19th Century non secular revivals. Additionally from the Burned-Over District:  Frances Willard, suffragette and founding father of the Girls’s Christian Temperance Union, which nonetheless has its headquarters in Evanston.

Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse will not be Midwestern cities, however once I go to there, I hear the identical speech I do in my native Midwest. The previous mayor of Niagara Falls referred to his state’s governor as “Eee-yen-drew Cuomo.” (His super-strong Inland North accent begins at 25:00 in this clip.) My good friend Mike Malyak, director of the Metal Plant Museum in Lackawanna, is a Dese, Dem and Dose Man, identical to his fellow white ethnics within the previous steelmaking communities of South Chicago.

When Syracuse native Terry McAuliffe ran for governor of Virginia, his opponent made enjoyable of his promise to carry “jahhhbs” to the state.

Inland North was as soon as thought of “normal” American speech, a lot so {that a} Southern linguist dubbed it SWINE: Normal White Inland North English. This was in all probability because of the truth that within the early 20th Century, the nation’s main pronunciation knowledgeable was John S. Kenyon, a philologist at Ohio’s Hiram School. Kenyon was the creator of American Pronunciation: A Pronouncing Dictionary of American English, and pronunciation editor of Webster’s New Worldwide Dictionary of the English Language. In these roles, Kenyon championed rhoticity, the pronunciation or “r”s wherever they seem in phrases. He additionally favored saying “not” like “naht,” as a substitute of “nawt.” These had been each options of the Inland North speech Kenyon heard in northeastern Ohio.

Nonetheless, Inland North speech has modified dramatically since Kenyon’s time, because of the Northern Cities Vowel Shift, a collection of pronunciation changes which makes “can” sound like “cay-en,” and “father” like “faaa-ther.” Remarkably, the Shift has been constant all through the Inland North, and has made us sound so distinct from the remainder of the nation that Saturday Night time Stay parodied our speech in two sketches. “The Superfans” made “Da Bears” a nationwide catchphrase, exaggerating the fronted “o”s of Chicagoans who love “Polish sahhhsage.” “1-600-LANSING” was a pretend advert a couple of telephone intercourse line for males turned on by girls with nasal Michigan accents. Household Man did a cutaway bit a couple of Wisconsin nymphomaniac who cries “Oh Gahhhd” and “Oh cray-ep” throughout intercourse.

I’ve by no means seen an SNL skit in regards to the Rochester accent, however as Robert Forster demonstrated, that’s what we communicate with right here. Our Midwestern accents aren’t Midwestern in any respect: we borrowed them from someplace else.

Most Popular

Chicago’s Most Anticipated Restaurant Openings for 2021

Despite more than 12 months of grueling pandemic struggles, hope springs eternal: in March,...

An Architect Couple Get to Live in Their Dream Home

Lap Chi Kwong and Alison Von Glinow gave their Edgewater residence a curved atrium instead of a traditional entrance foyer and hallway. Photography: James...

Recent Comments